Button Flies Are Stupid
I feel like I need to rant for a minute…
Is it just me, or does every style-minded guy have some comment he read on the internet ages ago forever rattling around in his memory taking up WAY too much space, regardless of its veracity?
In those early years of trying to get my sartorial legs under me, I pored over menswear websites and forums soaking up as much advice as I could. I hardly knew anything at the time, so my brain, unfortunately, was ripe for being influenced by anyone with an opinion and even a modicum of confidence.
At one point I saw a thread discussing zipper flies versus button flies. I remember one commenter saying that he always gets button flies on his bespoke suits since they are more elegant, classic, they lie better, and are more functional and practical than a zipper.
I didn’t really give it much thought at the time since I was light years away from commissioning bespoke suits (I still am, come to think of it). But I just took it as truth that button flies were better than zippers.
I saw the same debate when it came to jeans. People seemed to LOVE their old Levi’s with button flies and would actively seek out jeans with that feature.
Now that I am a real adult with semi-cogent opinions of my own (and more than a few years of practice draping pretty cloth over my body), I can confidently say that button flies are stupid and there are no real benefits to button flies compared with zipper flies.
First of all, people who love button flies say that they’re better because they are more classic than zippers. They were the OG way to close your pants and, for them, that’s often enough.
Ok, I get that buttons predate zippers. But why does the fact that pants originally had button flies mean that they’re better than zipper flies? Of course not. Something isn’t better solely because it was the way it was originally done.
Personally, I HATE button flies. I find them horribly impractical, mainly when using the men’s room. Not to get too graphic, but there’s definitely an ease when using a zipper that simply doesn’t exist when you have to unbutton and button a handful of steel shanks just to do your business.
And the whole “elegance” thing is really dumb. No one should be able to see your buttons/zipper anyway, since they are covered with the flap of cloth. Your pants could be held together like a Ziploc bag and it wouldn’t matter, as long as they stayed closed. So, your pants aren’t automatically more “formal” or “correct” because you opt for buttons over a zipper.
I can’t think of one real benefit of buttons over zippers.
Durability maybe? Nah, that can’t be a real reason. I have never once in my life had a zipper break on a pair of pants.
I’ve seen people mention how their fly will never come undone with buttons, but, again, I have never had a zipper fly come undone by itself. And if you forget to fasten your fly, it’s because you just forgot to do it. It doesn’t make a difference whether or not your fly closes with buttons or a zipper.
What about comfort? That’s can’t be a reason either. A thin, flexible zipper track is much more forgiving than a row of rigid buttons. And your pants shouldn’t be so tight that your fly is causing you discomfort anyway.
Phew! I’m glad I got that all off my chest! Maybe now I can finally exorcise that demon of a comment that has been living in my head for the past decade-plus.

Leave a Reply